This Article suggests that although one part of a corporate distribution may be analogous to a sale and the remainder to a dividend, there is no overlap of, or competition between, analogies. This lack of overlap is apparent when one realizes that a dividend and a sale are methods of realizing different types of gain, rather than alternative methods of realizing the same type of gain. This Article examines the basic conceptual model underlying the present system of taxing corporate distributions, describes the appropriate treatment of corporate distributions that is suggested by an understanding of the underlying concepts, and indicates the discrepancies between the present Code and this model.
Charles R.T. O'Kelley,
Corporate Distributions and the Income Tax: A Consideration of the Inconsistency between Subchapter C and Its Underlying Policy
Available at: http://digitalcommons.law.uga.edu/fac_artchop/253